Refine Search
Sort by
$225,000
2026037664 MLS
Fabulous Opportunity! Rarely offered! Build your North Captiva Island getaway on this desirable homesite within Safety Harbor Club, complete with a Class A Membership and access to an outstanding collection of island amenities. Ideally positioned near the heart of the community, the lot is convenient to the remodeled heated pool, clubhouse, tennis and pickleball courts, with the potential for lake views from the upper levels of a fantastic future residence and/or vacation home. For boating enthusiasts, one of the standout benefits is access to Safety Harbor Club’s shared docking facilities, providing options for small and large boats with dockage that can accommodate much larger vessels than most individual island slips. With two docking options - the community wharf and the T-dock plus the community kayak launch there are even more ways to enjoy North Captiva by water! Membership provides access to the community’s Gulf beach access, beach parking, boat dockage, pool, clubhouse, recreational facilities and other amenities, along with water, sewer and trash service. The club’s ferry landing and waterfront restaurant are also conveniently nearby. With key community infrastructure already established, building here may offer advantages compared with developing in other areas of the island. Create the island home you’ve envisioned and enjoy boating, kayaking, beach days, swimming, tennis, pickleball and waterfront dining as part of everyday life. This is a distinctive opportunity to own and build within one of North Captiva Island’s established amenity-rich communities.

4486 Hammock CT, Captiva

$135,000
2026033060 MLS
Build Your Private Island Dream Home --- Escape to paradise on exclusive Upper Captiva Island, where this remarkable piece of land offers the best of both worlds—beach and bay access. Nestled between the pristine shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the tranquil waters of Foster’s Bay, this lot is the ideal canvas for your dream island retreat. Surrounded by lush tropical foliage and located in a peaceful, car-free community, this property offers ultimate privacy and a true sense of seclusion. Whether you're seeking a luxurious second home or a one-of-a-kind vacation getaway, you’ll enjoy the rare combination of direct beach access for sun-soaked days and convenient bay access for paddleboarding, kayaking, and boating adventures. With no cars, no crowds, and unmatched natural beauty, Upper Captiva is a hidden gem where time slows down. This is your opportunity to create a custom island home in one of Florida’s most remote and magical settings. More pictures will be available at a later date

Captiva

$89,000
2026036139 MLS
Turn your dream of owning a piece of a tropical paradise into a reality with this North Captiva Island building lot! Perched on the picturesque north end of the island, this property is just a short walk from the bay and white-sand Gulf beaches. You'll have endless opportunities for fishing, dolphin watching, eagle spotting, shelling, and enjoying the island's amazing sunsets. If you are a pilot, this lot is also close to the Salty Approach Airstrip. North Captiva Island is exclusively accessed by boat or private plane, making it a fun and unique place to live or vacation. While you really won't ever want to leave, two regular ferries are running throughout the day that can conveniently take you and your guests to and from your tropical escape. As a bonus, this property already has a well (which could potentially save you over 20k)... one less thing to worry about when you build your new vacation or retirement home!

160 Mourning Dove DR, Captiva

$130,000
2026033875 MLS
SOUTHERN EXPOSURE AND THE OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD YOUR OWN ISLAND ESCAPE IN CASTAWAY KEY. Located on Upper Captiva, this homesite offers a great setting to design a custom home tailored to the relaxed Southwest Florida lifestyle. Southern exposure is ideal for enjoying abundant sunshine throughout the day and creating an outdoor living area that makes the most of the island setting. Whether you are planning a personal getaway, full time residence, or investment property, this lot gives you the flexibility to bring your vision to life. Spend your days enjoying the beach, boating, fishing, shelling, and everything that makes Upper Captiva such a unique destination. With a peaceful tropical atmosphere and the charm of Castaway Key, this is a great opportunity to create a home and lifestyle that feels like a true island retreat.

4471 Smugglers DR, Captiva

$130,000
2026033871 MLS
CASTAWAY KEY ISLAND LIVING STARTS HERE. This homesite on Upper Captiva offers the perfect opportunity to build your own private island retreat in the desirable Castaway Key community. Surrounded by the natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere that make Upper Captiva so special, this lot provides an ideal setting for a custom full time residence, vacation getaway, or investment property. Enjoy the unique island lifestyle with beautiful Gulf beaches, boating, fishing, shelling, and unforgettable sunsets all close by. With its tropical surroundings and peaceful setting, this property is a blank canvas ready for your vision. Build the home you have been dreaming of and create your own slice of paradise in Castaway Key on Upper Captiva.

4520 Smugglers DR, Captiva

$13,000,000
2026029362 MLS
Some places are discovered. Others are preserved. Only a select few become part of someone's legacy. Just beyond the shores of Captiva Island lies Buck Key—an extraordinary private island where untouched natural beauty, remarkable privacy, & limitless possibility converge. Opportunities of this magnitude have become exceedingly rare, making Buck Key one of the most compelling island offerings available anywhere in North America. Surrounded by the tranquil waters of Roosevelt Channel and Hurricane Hole, the island encompasses approximately 14 acres, highlighted by nearly 2,600 feet of shoreline, approximately 8.6 acres of uplands, a protected 10-acre lagoon, and a 13-foot construction-grade dock. Positioned within a remarkable 350-acre island sanctuary, Buck Key offers an unparalleled combination of seclusion and accessibility, just minutes from the restaurants, marinas, and world-renowned beaches of Captiva Island. This is not a property defined by what already exists—it is defined by what is possible. Imagine an architectural masterpiece rising above the mangroves. A private family compound passed from one generation to the next. A waterfront retreat designed entirely around your vision. Here, every sunrise arrives over protected coastal habitat, every evening concludes with Gulf sunsets, and every day offers boating, fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking, and the quiet luxury of complete privacy. In an era when waterfront land grows increasingly scarce and entitlement opportunities continue to diminish, Buck Key represents something that can no longer be replicated. It is a place where conservation and luxury coexist, where nature becomes the ultimate amenity, and where the opportunity to create something entirely bespoke remains remarkably intact. Legacy properties are seldom created. They are preserved, stewarded, and ultimately entrusted to those with the vision to recognize their significance. Buck Key is more than an island. It is an invitation to create something that will endure for generations.

Buck Key, Captiva

$130,000
2026019879 MLS
This is an exceptional buildable lot! Steps from the sugar sand beaches of North Captiva and the runway. Build your dream home or keep it simple and use the same builder that would have built for the seller's. Royal Corinthian Homes has a build design for this lot to see panoramic views with 5 bedrooms & 3 1/2 baths. Large open floor plan on top floor with kitchen & living area with sliders across entire house. Large picture window on the side of house to optimize water views. Master suite on the 3rd floor where the main living space and powder bath are. First flight has 4 bedrooms with a Jack and Jill bath and laundry room. You can also choose your own builder. Short walk or golf cart ride to beautiful wide sandy beaches, state preserve, restaurants, resort-style amenities & a ferry landing. Once built this would be a great potential for vacation rental income, secondary home or primary home.

200 Gold Finch DR, Captiva

$199,000
2026004719 MLS
You are looking to build your new getaway, but how do you get away from it all? A true barrier island with no bridges. Separate yourself from the world and enjoy the peace and quiet. It’s just you, your companions and the beach on North Captiva Island. Only accessible by boat or plane, this bay to beach lot offers expansive views of the Gulf of Mexico. The closely neighboring barrier island Sanibel is a popular tourist destination known for its unique shelling and beaches (due to the east/west orientation) and wildlife refuges. There are only a handful of bay to beach lots that are buildable on North Captiva Island. Build your sanctuary on one of the best rated beaches in Florida. Owner financing may be available, call for terms!!

12541 South Banks DR, Captiva

$170,000
2026013740 MLS
Here's your opportunity to own a piece of one of Southwest Florida's most coveted private islands. This vacant lot on Oro Pesos Lane offers a clean slate to build your custom island retreat on North Captiva — a boat-access-only barrier island where the pace slows, the crowds disappear, and the Florida you've been searching for actually exists. No bridge. No cars. No worries. North Captiva is one of the last truly undeveloped islands in Lee County, and this lot sits in the desirable Jose's Hideaway section of the island — walkable to the beach at the end of the street and close to all island amenities. Whether you're envisioning an elevated coastal home, a private fishing retreat, or a high-performing vacation rental, this lot delivers the fundamentals: a prime island address, a natural setting, and the kind of scarcity that protects long-term value. The adjoining lot is also available — purchase both together to double your property size and create nearly a half-acre parcel. Build a private compound, a main home with a guest house, or two separate income-producing properties with their own distinct addresses and street access. Opportunities like this simply don't exist on North Captiva. Short-term rental demand on North Captiva is strong and new construction commands premium nightly rates. Details on the building process, preferred island contractors, and revenue potential are available upon request

4521 Oro Pesos LN, Captiva

$78,400
2026010425 MLS
GREAT OPPORTUNITY on North Captiva Island! Fabulous Building Lot! Best-priced lot on the Central South Side of the Island AND located directly across from The Island Club at North Captiva (approximately 150 yards). This residential lot sits in a Desirable Area on the Island with a Very Short Walk to the Ferry, The Island Club at North Captiva, and all the amenities it has to offer. Lush and tropical, this is your chance to own a Piece of Paradise! Close to Butterfly Beach and a Short Distance to the Island's beautiful beaches and amenities. Come and Explore all that North Captiva Island has to Offer! Ferry services run all day, every day. Visit our Gorgeous Beaches and enjoy Amazing Fishing and Shelling. Drive a Golf Cart, Rent a Fat Tire Bike, or Walk the State Preserve while Admiring the Birds, Tortoises, Eagles, Manatees, Dolphins, and other Wildlife and Marine Life! Island Amenities include the Boats and Fun Store, Mango's Convenience Store, Mango's Outdoor Grill and Bar, the new Anchorage Steak House, the new Coconuts Outdoor Bar, The Island Club Gift Store, Mainstay Indoor and Outdoor Restaurant, Mainstay's Ice Cream and Gift Shop, Barnacle's Bar, and Over the Waterfront Restaurant at Safety Harbor.

516 Longboat CIR, Captiva

$430,000
2025022211 MLS
Sunrise and Sunset Views from this Rare Estate Lot bordering the 350 Acre State Preserve on North Captiva Island! Imagine building your dream home on this lot, where every day you can see glowing sunrises over acres of palm trees and seagrapes, and in the evenings, admire the Gulf sunsets painting the sky. Bordering protected state park land, this lot offers exceptional privacy, uninterrupted sightlines, and a front-row seat to island wildlife. Osprey flights at dawn, flocks of pelicans soaring past, flying in formation, glimpses of the local bald eagles, and the soft hush of nature all around you. On this property, the landscape doesn’t just surround you… it embraces you. Take a short stroll or golf cart ride down the street to one of the most expansive stretches of sugar sand on the island. The entrance to the state preserve hiking and biking trails is just a few hundred feet away. Very few vacant parcels on North Captiva combine preserve frontage, panoramic water views, estate-level space, and both sunrise and sunset vistas, making this a unique and wonderful place to enjoy your new island life.

751 Rum RD, Captiva

$5,650,000
2025013467 MLS
Situated along the most coveted stretch of Captiva Island’s Gold Coast, this 100-foot beachfront lot presents a rare opportunity to start fresh on one of the most iconic shorelines in Southwest Florida. Recently cleared, the property is ready for your vision, whether that means designing a custom beachfront retreat from the ground up or creating something truly extraordinary by combining it with the adjacent 200-foot beachfront parcel and the 100-foot bayfront property across the street. Together, these offerings present the potential for a one-of-a-kind waterfront compound spanning over 5.25 acres with 300 feet on the Gulf of Mexico and 100 feet on the Bay. Cherished as part of a family estate for over 40 years, this location offers dune-wide beachfront, sweeping views, and a level of privacy and serenity that is unmatched. Whether built as a standalone sanctuary or envisioned as part of a grand, multi-property estate, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create your own legacy on Captiva Island.

16548 Captiva DR, Captiva

$12,000,000
223058783 MLS
Discover an unparalleled beachfront jewel on the prestigious Gold Coast of Captiva Island. This 2-acre estate lot boasts a unique 153 ft of pristine beach frontage, uniquely situated on a stretch that naturally accumulates sand, ensuring lasting value and shoreline stability. Envision your dream compound with the freedom to build 3 distinct structures, all set against the backdrop of breathtaking sunsets, tranquil water vistas, and lush tropical foliage. Revel in the abundance of marine and wildlife, world-class fishing, boating, and the laid-back lifestyle that exemplifies the very essence of Florida living. Elevated high on a sand dune for superior views and protection, this property offers unrivaled value and luxury, setting it apart from other Florida retreats. Here, you're not just buying a property; you're securing a slice of paradise that truly represents why you live in Florida. Dive into the epitome of coastal elegance and allure. It’s paradise!

16280 Captiva DR, Captiva

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.