Browse All Sanibel FL Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224071112 MLS ⋅ Blind Pass Condo BLDG.

This first-floor condo in Blind Pass offers a unique "white box" opportunity, providing a blank canvas for you to create your ideal island retreat. Nestled on Sanibel Island's west end, the condo is just a short stroll from Bowman’s Beach, renowned for its exceptional shelling and close to the JN Ding Darling Wildlife Refuge. Surrounded by tropical vegetation, the path to the beach includes a scenic walk over a wooden footbridge spanning the bayou. Enjoy a morning coffee on the screened lanai on the tranquil side of the property and later in the day, meander down to the beach with your favorite refreshments to savor the stunning sunsets over the water. Blind Pass is a quaint complex of 7 buildings with 101 units, boasting resort-like amenities such as a heated pool, tennis courts, gas grills, and a community room. The unit features easy ground-level access and parking just beyond the lanai, a newly added A/C, and hurricane-proof windows and slider. The spacious 1200 sq ft offers a generous open living area with a split bedroom design, ideal for privacy and comfort. including an en-suite master bedroom. Ideal for both personal enjoyment and as an investment, the property comes with an optional onsite rental team to manage vacation rentals. Located just minutes from downtown Sanibel and Captiva Island, and directly connected to Sanibel’s extensive bike paths, this condo offers the perfect blend of secluded beach living and convenient access to local amenities. This opportunity is ideal for anyone dreaming of creating their own beachside retreat, blending the allure of a custom-designed home with the amenities and ease of resort-style living.

5117 Sea Bell RD Unit C101, Sanibel

$429,000

224069476 MLS

HERONS LANDING IN SANIBEL BAYOUS ONE LOT REMAINS This established neighborhood includes community amenities just steps across the street: POOL, SPA, AND TENNIS COURT. Deeded Beach access to one of the best shelling beaches in the world! Sanibel Island has so much to offer Nature Preserves, 26 miles of bike paths, charming shops, restaurants, and community events. A large, beautiful lot located in the quiet community of Heron's Landing is the perfect place to build your dream home and enjoy the natural beauty of Sanibel Island. Spec home plans are available.

5398 Osprey CT, Sanibel

$439,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 224069511 MLS ⋅ Captains Walk BLDG.

This quaint, East End community has a wonderful near beach location and is within walking/biking distance to great shopping and restaurants. Rare pet friendly community offers large courtyards, assigned covered parking, docks with canal access, wonderful for kayaking, SUP boards and fishing! Condo offers 2 bedrooms 1.5 bathrooms, living/dining room combination, screened porch, tile floors, new LVP in both bedrooms, freshly painted, new bathrooms, new kitchen with new GE appliances, new Roof, new HVAC, new impact windows and new impact sliding doors to be installed soon. Enjoy some of the world's best shelling and Sanibel's spectacular sunsets. The condo association is working diligently to finish all repairs. The complex was affected by hurricane Ian and has been fully remediated and repairs are getting close to completion.

561 Periwinkle WAY Unit F2, Sanibel

$410,000

224067032 MLS

Build your island dream home on this nearly half-acre, south-facing vacant lot in the coveted Sanibel Bayous neighborhood. Boasting over 105 feet of private waterfront, this partially cleared lot is primed for development. Enjoy exclusive deeded access to Bowman’s Beach, just a short stroll away. A comprehensive site development survey of the lot is available to potential buyers. Wetland delineation and environmental study by private consultant as well as Wetland Evaluation and Delineation conducted by FDEP / SLERC are also available. Parcel contains Ecological Zones F and D-2 (predominant zone), Allowable Impervious Coverage: 4,425 SF, Developed Area Allowed: 5,309 SF. Located on the desirable west end of Sanibel Island, this lot offers proximity to the natural wonders of J.N. 'Ding' Darling National Wildlife Refuge and the convenience of the Sanibel School with its popular recreation center. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to build your home in one of Sanibel’s most sought-after communities.

4626 Buck Key RD, Sanibel

$495,000

224068985 MLS

** OWNER FINANCE POSSIBLE ** "BEACHY SEA OATS COMMUNITY OF SANIBEL ISLAND" Prime Near Beach Homesite Off West Gulf - Deeded Beach Access and Only 8 Homes from Beach - Short Easy Walk to Beach. Build Your New Elevated Island Home. ** WESTERN EXPOSURE ** Beautiful Neighborhood with NO HOA FEES, Some lot Clearing has taken place, Central Utilities Available, see attachments

575 Sea Oats DR, Sanibel

$495,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 224060438 MLS ⋅ Tennisplace BLDG.

The Sanibel Island lifestyle is waiting for you! Don't miss out on this freshly renovated 2 bedroom 1 bathroom 2nd floor condo. This condo is located just steps from the Causeway Beach. You can even come view this one by boat. Pull right up to the brand new dock for this showing. One of the only completed, open and actively useable complexes on Sanibel. ALL SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS HAVE BEEN PAID! The unit was just remodeled with new granite counter tops and new appliances in the kitchen. Bathrooms were remodeled with new granite counter tops and new faucets. All of this beautiful Brand New Furniture is included. This unit is being sold turn key! It wouldn't be the Tennis Place condos without the beautiful double tennis courts. Low HOA, all new Metal roofs, all new AC condensers, soon to be newly painted exteriors and railings. The resurfaced, oversized heated swimming pool is open and ready for you to come and relax. Currently in a very successful vacation rental program. Rental details available on request.

1250 Tennisplace CT Unit A22, Sanibel

$475,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224034922 MLS

Storm Damaged AS-IS sale on a creek leading to a lake, great for kayaking. Ideal location close to downtown Sanibel, shopping, beach access and bike paths. Easy on & off island location. Pie shaped lot with 140+ feet of creek frontage. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac street.

1812 Ibis LN, Sanibel

$449,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 224035626 MLS ⋅ Tennisplace BLDG.

Welcome home to Tennisplace on Sanibel Island! Seize your opportunity to capture the charm of this well-established community that is beloved by primary residents, secondary/seasonal residents, and renters alike. The exceptional location of this top floor 2-bedroom 1.5-bathroom condominium offers the islands easiest on/off access by car or by boat, short walks to the Bay beaches, extremely close proximity to some of the islands most desirable restaurants and shops, premier boating access via direct, deep-water access right out your door, and the renowned Sanibel shared use path is right outside the campus! Tennisplace is a tremendous value and a dream for those in search of experiencing all that the island life can offer. Here, island time is in full effect and the most difficult decision to make is how to enjoy your day; Relaxing in the community pool or on the community docks watching the manatee, dolphin, and abundance of other marine life commuting to and from San Carlos Bay, sharpening your skills in a friendly game of tennis, pickleball, or basketball onsite, or taking advantage of the deeded beach access and discovering new treasures on the shell laden sugar sand beaches!

1250 Tennisplace CT Unit B32, Sanibel

$449,000

224019106 MLS

One of the few remaining parcels at The Sanctuary with wonderful privacy. Located near the Cul-De-Sac on Baltusrol with lower density and eastern exposure with preservation views beyond. The Sanctuary, is an Audubon recognized golf course designed by Arthur Hills. Stunning scenery and in harmony with nature. World class golf along with exceptional amenities are at your fingertips in addition to being very close to the beautiful beaches on the west part of Sanibel. The adjacent lot is also for sale making this a unique opportunity to buy both to afford the ultimate in privacy in perpetuity.

5648 Baltusrol CT, Sanibel

$439,000

224019102 MLS

One of the few remaining parcels at The Sanctuary with wonderful privacy. Located near the Cul-De-Sac on Baltursol with lower density and eastern exposure with preservation views beyond. The Sanctuary, is an Audubon recognized golf course designed by Arthur Hills. Stunning scenery and in harmony with nature. World class golf along with exceptional amenities are at your fingertips in addition to being very close to the beautiful beaches on the west part of Sanibel. The adjacent lot is also for sale making this a unique opportunity to buy both to afford the ultimate in privacy in perpetuity.

5642 Baltusrol CT, Sanibel

$499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224018751 MLS

PRICED TO SELL! Located in the highly desirable near beach West Rocks community on Sanibel Island, this 3/2 lake front home is down to the studs and just waiting for someone to reimagine it's potential. Sitting on a little over a quarter acre lot, this home provides lake views in a thoughtful layout with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, multiple living areas, 2 fireplaces, terrazzo floors, lots of storage, and a fishing/observation deck on the lake. Whether looking to renovate the existing structure or build new, 4049 Coquina Drive offers a fantastic island location and opportunity. The popular West Rocks community is just a short walk to West Gulf Drive beach access #3. Property was impacted by Hurricane Ian.

4049 Coquina DR, Sanibel

$499,000

224017899 MLS

An exceptional near beach parcel with good elevation, that also backs up to preservation land to ensure supreme privacy in perpetuity. This ideal cul-de-sac location is just steps to deeded beach access across from the entrance to this small community off of West Gulf Drive. This parcel is also altered land which allows for greater development coverage. The measured sqfg is 14,095sqft. Owners can build to suit.

4019 Coquina DR, Sanibel

$490,000

224012239 MLS

Reduced to sell. Sold together with 247 Robinwood Dr to make a 2 acre double lot with a lake. The price is for ONE lot. Combined lot is suitable for a single family home construction. Deeded beach access located off of West Gulf Drive. Both parcels sold together. Unique opportunity to have a large private lot on the second line from the beach!

255 Robinwood CIR, Sanibel

$490,000

224011943 MLS

Reduced to sell. Sold together with 255 Robinwood Dr to make a 2 acre double lot with a lake!!! The price is for ONE lot. Combined lot is suitable for a single family home construction. Deeded beach access located off of West Gulf Drive. Both parcels sold together. Unique opportunity to have a large private lot on the second line from the beach!

247 Robinwood CIR, Sanibel

$449,000

224007718 MLS

One of the best locations available in the Sanctuary offered for sale today with Eastern exposure, golf course views and a preservation buffer in the distance to maintain and enhance privacy. The Sanctuary Golf Club is an Audubon, Platinumr ecognized 18-hole championship golf course designed by Arthur Hills. Stunning scenery with nature everywhere. World class clubhouse, fitness center, tennis courts, restaurant can be yours with the purchase of an equity golf membership or social-sportsmembership. Call the Sanctuary membership coordinator Kathryn Riggio for details.

2438 Wulfert RD, Sanibel

$450,000

223061257 MLS

Discover the perfect canvas for your dream home at 1032 Sand Castle Road, located in the serene and sought-after Dunes community of Sanibel, Florida. This exceptional buildable lot presents an unparalleled opportunity to create your own retreat that captures the essence of coastal living. Nestled in the heart of Sanibel, this lot offers proximity to the island's beautiful beaches, vibrant local culture, and convenient amenities, ensuring a lifestyle that is both relaxed and convenient. A complete set of building plans is available for the new Buyer upon request! Don't Miss Out: Seize the chance to transform your aspirations into reality.

1032 Sand Castle RD, Sanibel

$445,000

223039525 MLS

Welcome to 1653 Bunting Lane! This vacant buildable corner lot presents a rare opportunity to own a prime piece of real estate in the coveted Gumbo Limbo neighborhood on Sanibel Island. Spanning .56 acres this spacious lot offers endless possibilities to create your dream home. An added highlight of this property is the existing 1 year old swimming pool. The pool adds a touch of luxury and relaxation to your future residence not to mention the cost savings! Don't miss this incredible opportunity to design and build your own custom home in one of Sanibel's most desirable areas. Create the ultimate sanctuary that perfectly aligns with your unique vision. With a vacant lot and an existing swimming pool as the foundation, the possibilities are endless. Claim your piece of paradise!

1653 Bunting LN, Sanibel

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

Between $400K - $500K Sanibel Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Sanibel and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!